Wednesday, February 9, 2011

Oak Ridge Schools Year-Round Debate

"No more pencils, no more books..." Remember that little end of school ditty you learned to sing as you and all your classmates ran from school at break-neck speed to dive into the family wagon? It signified the end of the school year and the beginning of summer break- think ocean, beach, tan, oh blissful sleep...

Well, the talk around town lately has those rosy images of spending summer lazing around the neighborhood pool fading fast. It seems that Oak Ridge is currently kicking around the idea of transitioning all of the city's schools onto a year-round schedule.This would mean that the kids would go by the 45-15 calendar- or 45 days in and 15 out. Basically, the kids would have 9 weeks of school, and then a 3 week vacation.

As a mother of four, three of which are currently attending Oak Ridge schools, I have mixed feelings concerning this debate.

Let me start off by saying that one of the primary reasons that my husband and I chose to move into Oak Ridge in the first place was because of the reputation of the public school system here- and as of yet, we have not been disappointed... Oh, don't get me wrong, as it goes with building any relationship- there have been some growing pains and a few bumps and scrapes along the way, but overall, the schools that our daughters are attending have been well worth our time and consideration. We are VERY satisfied with all of our daughters' progress so far. That being said, I do have conflicted feelings on the issue of converting ALL the schools to a year-round program.

We do have a child that is already on the year-round schedule. She attends the preschool and is really thriving in the school program. It is not at all an exaggeration to say She LOVES school! This is so cool, because my husband and I were reluctant to send her at first. She has had a little growth spurt recently, but she is still the smallest in her class. Try to imagine an 18 month old in a classroom full of rambunctious 3 year olds and you can picture what we saw on our daughter's first day of school. Our daughter is 3 years old, but her height and build looked more like that of an 18 month to 2 year old toddler. Her classmates were giants in comparison- and they all wanted to treat her like a little doll baby! Her teacher recently confided in me that initially she was worried that our daughter should be in a toddler class due to her tiny stature, but she has really made such wonderful progress! We have known since she was a baby that she needed extra help, and that she was developmentally delayed, but last year we discovered through genetic testing she has a rare genetic condition which will require her to need some extra guidance and therapies, probably for life.

For my child, and children with special needs like her, year-round school makes sense. The breaks are shorter, so they don't have as much time to fall out of the school routine, or miss out on any of the necessary therapies that they receive during school. For us- the stimulation she receives at school of playing with other little people her own age- yes, she has siblings, but they are either older sisters that dote on her, or a younger sissy that she gets to baby- is something that has been an integral part of her making so much progress this year. To be around children her age, where she can watch and see how they communicate, play, and interact with the world around them on a daily basis- this has really made a major impact on her personal growth, and maturity this school year.

For her and kids like her that need and thrive on the constant stimulation and active schedule that they experience in school, the year-round schedule is really a positive. Especially when you factor in that all children may experience some regression when school is out of session, however, in children with special needs or those who are at risk for other reasons- there is a greater level of regression that occurs in between semesters.

On the other hand- my two oldest daughters attend a very good elementary school that is on the regular schedule, and we have no real issues with it. My older girls love school, and are right on track with their studies. I couldn't be prouder of them actually! The summer comes and I find I am relieved to enjoy a little down time with all the girls together. As adults we are used to the regular school year, after all- it's the same schedule we grew up with as kids, hence it's comfortable for us- and for many parents. A lot of my friends point out that they do their big family vacations during the summer. My husband and I always talk of planning that grand summer vacation trekking across country to see the Grand Canyon and do Route 66 or do our 1st big out of country trip to Austrailia... but so far, that's all it is- talk.

A friend of mine put it best when she said- "if it ain't broke, don't fix it!" And this is probably the collective opinion of many parents here. Overall- the satisfaction level we have with the Oak Ridge school system is pretty high- will this be compromised if all the schools go to a year-round schedule? Will resources become strained? I think our concerns as parents should be ultimately, how does this benefit our children- and will it benefit them in the long run?

A year-round schedule would throw us all off in the immediate moment, in the right now of things, but in the long haul scheme of things, being in school year-round- won't that prepare them for the later reality of the work-force? None of us adults get a 3 month summer vacation from work- unless you are a teacher that is... On the other hand, a friend with teenagers pointed out that her kids all got their very first jobs in the summer. There are high-school kids who plan on summer as a big source of income- working at the local pool, gyms, or shops full-time so they can earn extra money for college, to pay off a car, or buy a cell phone. These are extremely valuable life lessons that come into play for many teenagers. I remember I got my first job in a bakery one summer galaxies ago, then at Woolworth's pet shop. I was fourteen- and I learned valuable lessons about personal and financial responsibility. Sure, these kids could get jobs during the school year- but then there would be the stress of work competing with academics, sports, and other
extracurricular activities.

At this point in time, I don't really see the year-round calendar as a necessity for most of the schools. I think it's a good option for children that have special considerations, or circumstances. I think it will take a lot more discussion at this point to get all of the parents on board with the idea.

What's your opinion on this issue?

No comments: